Filtering Semantics for Counterfactuals: Bridging Causal Models and Premise Semantics

Paolo Santorio


I argue that classical counterfactual semantics in the style of Stalnaker, Lewis, and Kratzer validates an inference pattern that is disconfirmed in natural language. The solution is to alter the algorithm we use to handle inconsistency in premise sets: rather than checking all maximally consistent fragments of a premise sets, as in Krazter's semantics, we selectively remove some of the premises. The proposed implementation starts from standard premise semantics and involves a new 'filtering' operation that achieves just this removal. The resulting semantics is interestingly related to the semantics for counterfactuals emerging from Judea Pearl's causal models framework in computer science: in particular, filtering is a possible worlds semantics counterpart of Pearl's interventions.

Full Text:



Briggs, Rachael. 2012. Interventionist counterfactuals. Philosophical studies 160(1). 139–166.

Burgess, John P. 1981. Quick completeness proofs for some logics of conditionals. Notre Dame Journal of Formal Logic 22(1). 76–84.

Chisholm, Roderick M. 1946. The contrary-to-fact conditional. Mind 55(219). 289–307.

Fine, Kit. 1975. Review of lewis’ counterfactuals. Mind 84. 451–458.

Fine, Kit. 2012a. Counterfactuals without possible worlds. Journal of Philosophy 109(3). 221–246.

Fine, Kit. 2012b. A difficulty for the possible worlds analysis of counterfactuals. Synthese 189(1). 29–57.

Galles, David & Judea Pearl. 1998. An axiomatic characterization of causal counterfactuals. Foundations of Science 3(1). 151–182.

Goodman, Nelson. 1947. The problem of counterfactual conditionals. The Journal of Philosophy 44(5). 113–128.

Groenendijk, Jerome & Martin Stokhof. 1984. Studies in the Semantics of Questions and the Pragmatics of Answers: University of Amsterdam dissertation.

Halpern, Joseph Y. 2013. From causal models to counterfactual structures. Review of Symbolic Logic 6(2). 305–322.

Hiddleston, Eric. 2005. A causal theory of counterfactuals. Noûs 39(4). 632–657.

Ippolito, Michela. 2013. Counterfactuals and conditional questions under discussion. In Proceedings of SALT 23, 194–211.

Kaufmann, Stefan. 2013. Causal premise semantics. Cognitive science 37(6). 1136–1170.

Kratzer, Angelika. 1981a. The notional category of modality. In H. J. Eikmeyer & H. Rieser (eds.), Words, Worlds, and Contexts: New Approaches to Word Semantics, Berlin: de Gruyter.

Kratzer, Angelika. 1981b. Partition and revision: The semantics of counterfactuals. Journal of Philosophical Logic 10(2). 201–216.

Kratzer, Angelika. 1986. Conditionals. In Chicago Linguistics Society: Papers from the Parasession on Pragmatics and Grammatical Theory, vol. 22 2, 1–15. University of Chicago, Chicago IL: Chicago Linguistic Society.

Kratzer, Angelika. 1991. Modality. Semantics: An international handbook of contemporary research 639–650.

Kratzer, Angelika. 2012. Modals and Conditionals: New and Revised Perspectives, vol. 36. Oxford University Press.

Kraus, Sarit, Daniel Lehmann & Menachem Magidor. 1990. Nonmonotonic reasoning, preferential models and cumulative logics. Artificial intelligence 44(1). 167–207.

Lewis, David K. 1973a. Counterfactuals. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Lewis, David K. 1973b. Counterfactuals and comparative possibility. Journal of Philosophical Logic 2(4). 418–446.

Lewis, David K. 1981. Ordering semantics and premise semantics for counterfactuals. Journal of Philosophical Logic 10(2). 217–234.

Nute, Donald. 1975. Counterfactuals and the similarity of words. The Journal of Philosophy 72(21). 773–778.

Pearl, Judea. 2000. Causality: models, reasoning and inference. Cambridge University Press


Santorio, Paolo. 2014a. Causal models and counterfactual logic: Experimental data. In preparation.

Santorio, Paolo. 2014b. Interventions in premise semantics. Manuscript, University of Leeds.

Schulz, Katrin. 2011. If you’d wiggled a, then b would’ve changed. Synthese 179(2). 239–251.

Slote, Michael A. 1978. Time in counterfactuals. The Philosophical Review 87(1). 3–27.

Stalnaker, Robert. 1968. A theory of conditionals. In N. Recher (ed.), Studies in Logical Theory, Oxford.

Veltman, Frank. 1976. Prejudices, presuppositions, and the theory of counterfactuals. In Amsterdam Papers in Formal Grammar. Proceedings of the 1st Amsterdam Colloquium, 248–281. University of Amsterdam.


Add comment