Surface Correspondence and Discrete Harmony Triggers

Rachel Walker


Correspondence relations among segments in an output, known as surface correspondence, provide a means for enforcing (dis)agreement among segments (Hansson 2001, Rose & Walker 2004, Bennett 2013). This paper examines implications of partially overlapping harmony patterns for the formal properties of surface correspondence. A novel and unwanted typological prediction of transitive surface correspondence relations with chain-adjacent evaluation of identity is identified, dubbed the Closest Correspondent Trigger Prediction. The problem is exemplified by the interaction of two overlapping vowel harmonies in the Pasiego Montañes dialect, where a target vowel agrees with different trigger segments for different features. A revised feature-restricted evaluation of identity constraints that operate over surface correspondents is proposed, where evaluation is restricted to the subset of correspondents that share a given set of features. This move merges the previous division of labor in surface correspondence theory between constraints that promote interactions among similar segments and those that enforce identity between them. The result is a theory where surface identity constraints are the prime locus of pattern-shaping and the role for constraints that drive surface correspondence is reduced. Future directions on the status of constraints that drive surface correspondence and the treatment of locality are considered.


Pasiego Montañes; Vowel Harmony; Surface Correspondence; Agreement by Correspondence

Full Text:



Bennett, William. 2013. Dissimilation, Consonant Harmony, and Surface Correspondence. Ph.D. dissertation, Rutgers University.

Bennett, William. To appear. Assimilation, dissimilation, and surface correspondence in Sundanese. Natural Language and Linguistic Theory.

Bowman, Samuel R. & Benjamin Lokshin. 2014. Idiosyncratically transparent vowels in Kazakh. Proceedings of the 2013 Annual Meeting on Phonology.

Flemming, Edward. 1993. The role of metrical structure in segmental rules. M.A. thesis, UCLA.

Hansson, Gunnar Ó. 2001. Theoretical and Typological Issues in Consonant Harmony. Ph.D. dissertation, University of California, Berkeley.

Hansson, Gunnar Ó. 2006a. Locality and similarity in phonological agreement. Paper presented at the workshop on Current Perspectives on Phonology. Indiana University, June 23, 2006.

Hansson, Gunnar Ó. 2006b. Understanding harmony as agreement. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Linguistic Society of America, Albuquerque, NM, January 2006.

Hansson, Gunnar Ó. 2007. Blocking effects in agreement by correspondence. Linguistic Inquiry 38, 395–409.

Hansson, Gunnar Ó. 2010. Consonant Harmony: Long-Distance Interaction in Phonology. Berkeley: University of California Press.

Hannson, Gunnar Ó. 2014. (Dis)agreement by (non)correspondence: Inspecting the foundations. Paper presented at the ABC Conference, University of California, Berkeley, May 18, 2014. [Slides archived in UC Berkeley Phonology Lab 2014 Annual Report: ABC <-> Conference Archive, 3–62.]

Hayes, Bruce & Zsuzsa Londe. 2006. Stochastic phonological knowledge: The case of Hungarian vowel harmony. Phonology 53, 59–104.

Hualde, José I. 1989. Autosegmental and metrical spreading in the vowel-harmony systems of northwestern Spain. Linguistics 27, 773–805.

Inkelas, Sharon & Stephanie S. Shih. 2014. Unstable surface correspondence as the source of local conspiracies. Proceedings of the 44th North East Linguistic Society, 191–204. Amherst, MA: GLSA.

Kaun, Abigail. 1995. The Typology of Rounding Harmony: An Optimality Theoretic Approach. Ph.D. dissertation, UCLA.

Kirchner, Robert. 1993. Turkish vowel harmony and disharmony: An optimality theoretic account. Paper presented at the Rutgers Optimality Workshop 1, Rutgers University, New Brunswick, NJ, October 22, 1993.

Legendre, Geraldine, Yoshiro Miyata & Paul Smolensky. 1990. Harmonic Grammar – A formal multi-level connectionist theory of linguistic well-formedness: An application. Proceedings of the Twelfth Annual Conference of the Cognitive Science Society, 884–891. Cambridge, MA: Lawrence Erlbaum.

Lionnet, Florian. 2014. Doubly triggered rounding harmony in Laal. Proceedings of the 2013 Annual Meeting on Phonology.

McCarthy, John J. 1984. Theoretical consequences of Montañes vowel harmony. Linguistic Inquiry 15, 291–318.

McCarthy, John J. 2010. Agreement by Correspondence without Corr constraints. Ms., University of Massachusetts, Amherst. (Available as ROA-1089.)

McCarthy, John J. & Alan Prince. 1995. Faithfulness and reduplicative identity. In Jill Beckman, Laura Walsh-Dickey & Suzanne Urbanczyk (eds.), University of Massachusetts Occasional Papers: Papers in Optimality Theory, 249–384. Amherst, MA: GLSA.

Padgett, Jaye. 2002. Feature classes in phonology. Langauge 78, 81–110.

Padgett, Jaye. 2008. Glides, vowels, and features. Lingua 118, 1937–1955.

Penny, Ralph. 1969a. El habla pasiega: ensayo de dialectologia montañesa. London: Tamesis.

Penny, Ralph. 1969b. Vowel harmony in the speech of the Montes de Pas (Santander). Orbis 18, 148–166.

Penny, Ralph. 1970. Mass nouns and metaphony in the dialects of north-western Spain. Archivum Linguisticum 1, 21–30.

Pulleyblank, Douglas. 2002. Harmony drivers: No disagreement allowed. Proceedings of the 28th Annual Meeting of the Berkeley Linguistic Society, 249–267. Berkeley, CA.

Rhodes, Russell. 2012. Vowel harmony as Agreement by Correspondence. UC Berkeley Phonology Lab Annual Report, 138–168. University of California, Berkeley.

Rose, Sharon & Rachel Walker. 2004. A typology of consonant agreement as correspondence. Language 80, 475–531.

Sasa, Tomomasa. 2009. Treatments of Vowel Harmony in Optimality Theory. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Iowa.

Shih, Stephanie S. 2013. Consonant-tone interaction as Agreement by Correspondence. Ms., University of California, Berkeley and Stanford University.

Shih, Stephanie S. & Sharon Inkelas. 2014. A subsegmental correspondence approach to contour tone (dis)harmony patterns. Proceedings of the 2013 Annual Meeting on Phonology.

Smolensky, Paul & Geraldine Legendre. 2006. The Harmonic Mind: From Neural Computation to Optimality-Theoretic Grammar. Vol. 1: Cognitive Architecture; Vol. 2: Linguistic and Philosophical Implications. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Sylak-Glassman, John, Stephanie Farmer & Lev Michael. 2014. An Agreement by Correspondence analysis of Máíhiki nasalization harmony. Paper presented at the ABC Conference, UC Berkeley, May 19, 2014. [Handout archived in UC Berkeley Phonology Lab 2014 Annual Report: ABC <-> Conference Archive, 223–287.]

Vago, Robert. 1988. Underspecification in the dual harmony system of Pasiego (Spanish). Phonology 5, 343–362.

Walker, Rachel. 2000a. Long-distance consonantal identity effects. Proceedings of the 19th West Coast Conference on Formal Linguistics, 532–545. Somerville, MA: Cascadilla Press.

Walker, Rachel. 2000b. Yaka nasal harmony: Spreading or segmental correspondence? Proceedings of the 26th Annual Meeting of the Berkeley Linguistic Society, 321–332. Berkeley, CA.

Walker, Rachel. 2001. Consonantal correspondence. Proceedings of the Workshop on the Lexicon in Phonetics and Phonology. Papers in Experimental and Theoretical Linguistics, Vol. 6, 73–84. Edmonton: Department of Linguistics, University of Alberta.

Walker, Rachel. 2009. Similarity-sensitive blocking and transparency in Menominee. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Linguistic Society of America, San Francisco, CA, January 9, 2009.

Walker, Rachel. 2014. Prominence-control and multiple triggers in vowel harmony: An ABC analysis. Paper presented at the ABC Conference, UC Berkeley, May 19, 2014. [Handout archived in UC Berkeley Phonology Lab 2014 Annual Report: ABC <-> Conference Archive, 202–213.]

Wayment, Adam. 2009. Assimilation as Attraction: Computing Distance, Similarity, and Locality in Phonology. Ph.D. dissertation, Johns Hopkins University.

Zymet, Jesse. 2014. Distance-based decay in long-distance phonological processes: Probabilistic models for Malagasy, Latin, English and Hungarian. M.A. thesis, UCLA.


Copyright (c) 2016 Rachel Walker

License URL: