Reviewed by Picus S. Ding, Macao Polytechnic Institute
In this second and revised edition, Natsuko Tsujimura presents a well-versed introduction to Japanese linguistics. The textbook is composed of eight chapters (each with suggested readings and exercises of varying lengths at the end), a bibliography, and an index. Ch. 1 (1–4) is a brief introduction. Ch. 2 (5–19) compares the sounds of English, when applicable, to the sounds of Japanese. Ch. 3 (20–113), which discusses the phonological rules of Japanese, introduces crucial concepts such as mora, accentuation, and mimetics.
Ch. 4 (114–205) is dedicated to Japanese morphology, addressing parts of speech, word formation (particularly compounding), transitive-intransitive verb pairs, and deverbal nouns. Ch. 5 (206–339) focuses on the syntax of Japanese, dealing with the scrambling phenomenon, null anaphora, reflexives, the notion of subject, passives, causatives, relative clauses, unaccusativity, and the light verb construction. Ch. 6 (340–421), which mainly concerns semantics, discusses word and sentence meaning as well as tense and aspect in Japanese. This chapter also covers the semantic classes of verbs and pragmatic issues such as the different information status signaled by the particles wa and ga.
Ch. 7 (422–43) explores Japanese language variation in terms of geographic region, level of speech, and gender. Ch. 8 (444–76) looks at how children acquire Japanese. T explores the acquisition of mora, lexicalization patterns with mimetics, morphological rules, and varied forms of styles and levels of speech.
This volume provides an eye-opening introduction to Japanese linguistics as well as to the Japanese language. It reflects the influence of English linguistic analysis on Japanese linguistics. However, there are a few points that should be clarified further in the textbook. While the concept of a bimoraic foot can satisfactorily account for accentuation on compounds, it is unclear which of the two morae on the penultimate foot would bear the accent. Dialectal comparison shows that hasi can bear three accentuation patterns in Kyoto Japanese (e.g. low-high [LH] for ‘chopsticks’, HL for ‘bridge’, and HH for ‘edge’), whereas only two patterns occur in these words in Tokyo Japanese (e.g. HL for ‘chopsticks’ and LH for both ‘bridge’ and ‘edge’; 426). However, if we consider that the surface accentuation pattern in Japanese is derived from underlying suprasegmental categories (Ding 2006), the number of lexical contrasts for these three words will be maintained across the two dialects.
Furthermore, Kitagawa (1980) has pointed out the problem of using reflexivization to diagnose subjecthood in Japanese—namely, that coreference between the subject and the reflexive word zibun does not always hold (329). The use of subject honorification for this purpose is also questionable, unless the particular honorification could equally apply to the subject of passive sentences. It seems that other grammatical criteria should be sought to establish a clearly defined subject in Japanese.
References
DING, PICUS SIZHI. 2006. A typological study of tonal systems of Japanese and Prinmi. Journal of Universal Language 7.1–35.
Kitagawa, Chisato. 1980. Review of Problems in Japanese syntax and semantics, ed. by John Hinds and Irwin Howard. Tokyo: Kaitakusha, 1978. Language 56.435–40.