Probabilistic language in indicative and counterfactual conditionals

Daniel Lassiter


This paper analyzes indicative and counterfactual conditionals that have in their consequents probability operators: probable, likely, more likely than not, 50% chance and so on. I provide and motivate a unified compositional semantics for both kinds of probabilistic conditionals using a Kratzerian syntax for conditionals and a representation of information based on Causal Bayes Nets. On this account, the only difference between probabilistic indicatives and counterfactuals lies in the distinction between conditioning and intervening. This proposal explains why causal (ir)relevance is crucial for probabilistic counterfactuals, and why it plays no direct role in probabilistic indicatives. I conclude with some complexities related to the treatment of backtracking counterfactuals and subtleties revealed by probabilistic language in the revision procedure used to create counterfactual scenarios. In particular, I argue that certain facts about the interaction between probability operators and counterfactuals motivate the use of Structural Equation Models (Pearl 2000) rather than the more general formalism of Causal Bayes Nets.

Full Text:



Adams, Ernest W. 1975. The Logic of Conditionals: An Application of Probability to Deductive Logic. Springer.

Arregui, Ana Cristina. 2005. On the accessibility of possible worlds: The role of tense and aspect: University of Massachusetts PhD dissertation.

Barker, Stephen. 1998. Predetermination and tense probabilism. Analysis 58(4). 290–296.

Barker, Stephen. 1999. Counterfactuals, probabilistic counterfactuals and causation. Mind 108(431). 427–469.

Belnap, Nuel & Mitchell Green. 1994. Indeterminism and the thin red line. Philosophical perspectives 8. 365–388.

Bennett, Jonathan F. 2003. A Philosophical Guide to Conditionals. Oxford University Press.

Briggs, Rachael. 2012. Interventionist counterfactuals. Philosophical studies 160(1). 139–166.

Ciardelli, Ivano, Linmin Zhang & Lucas Champollion. 2017. Two switches in the theory of counterfactuals: A study of truth conditionality and minimal change. To appear in Linguistics & Philosophy.

Danks, David. 2014. Unifying the Mind: Cognitive Representations as Graphical Models. MIT Press.

Dehghani, Morteza, Rumen Iliev & Stefan Kaufmann. 2012. Causal explanation and fact mutability in counterfactual reasoning. Mind & Language 27(1). 55–85.

Edgington, Dorothy. 1995. On conditionals. Mind 104(414). 235–329.

Edgington, Dorothy. 2004. Counterfactuals and the benefit of hindsight. In Phil Dowe & Paul Noordhof (eds.), Cause and Chance: Causation in an Indeterministic World, Routledge.

Edgington, Dorothy. 2008. Counterfactuals. In Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 108 1, 1–21.

Gerstenberg, Tobias, Christos Bechlivanidis & David A Lagnado. 2013. Back on track: Backtracking in counterfactual reasoning, .

Glymour, Clark N. 2001. The Mind’s Arrows: Bayes Nets and Graphical Causal Models in Psychology. MIT press.

Goodman, Nelson. 1947. The problem of counterfactual conditionals. The Journal of Philosophy 44(5). 113–128.

Gopnik, Alison & Laura Schultz (eds.). 2007. Causal Learning: Psychology, Philosophy, and Computation. Oxford University Press.

Griffiths, Thomas L., Charles Kemp & Joshua B. Tenenbaum. 2008. Bayesian models of cognition. In Ron Sun (ed.), Cambridge Handbook of Computational Psychology, 59–100. Cambridge University Press.

Hiddleston, Eric. 2005. A causal theory of counterfactuals. Noûs 39(4). 632–657.

Jackson, Frank. 1977. A causal theory of counterfactuals. Australasian Journal of Philosophy 55(1). 3–21.

Kaufmann, Stefan. 2001a. Aspects of the meaning and use of conditionals: Stanford University PhD dissertation.

Kaufmann, Stefan. 2001b. Tense probabilism properly conceived. In Proceedings of the Thirteenth Amsterdam Colloquium, 132–137.

Kaufmann, Stefan. 2005. Conditional predictions: A probabilistic account. Linguistics and Philosophy 28(2). 181–231. doi:10.1007/s10988-005-3731-9.

Kaufmann, Stefan. 2009. Conditionals right and left: Probabilities for the whole family. Journal of Philosophical Logic 38(1). 1–53. doi:10.1007/s10992-008- 9088-0.

Kaufmann, Stefan. 2013. Causal premise semantics. Cognitive science 37(6). 1136–1170.

Khoo, Justin. 2016. Backtracking counterfactuals revisited. Mind .

Kratzer, Angelika. 1981. The notional category of modality. In Eikmeyer & Rieser (eds.), Words, Worlds, and Contexts, 38–74. de Gruyter.

Kratzer, Angelika. 1989. An investigation of the lumps of thought. Linguistics and Philosophy 12(5). 607–653.

Kratzer, Angelika. 1991a. Conditionals. In A. von Stechow & D. Wunderlich

(eds.), Semantik: Ein internationales Handbuch der zeitgenössischen Forschung, 651–656. Walter de Gruyter.

Kratzer, Angelika. 1991b. Modality. In Arnim von Stechow & Dieter Wunderlich (eds.), Semantik: Ein internationales Handbuch der zeitgenössischen Forschung, 639–650. Walter de Gruyter.

Kvart, Igal. 1986. A theory of counterfactuals. Hackett.

Kvart, Igal. 1992. Counterfactuals. Erkenntnis 36(2). 139–179.

Lassiter, Daniel. 2010. Gradable epistemic modals, probability, and scale structure. In Nan Li & David Lutz (eds.), Semantics & Linguistic Theory (SALT) 20, 197–215. CLC Publications.

Lassiter, Daniel. 2015. Epistemic comparison, models of uncertainty, and the disjunction puzzle. Journal of Semantics 32(4). 649–684.

Lassiter, Daniel. 2017a. Graded Modality: Qualitative and Quantitative Perspectives. Oxford University Press.

Lassiter, Daniel. 2017b. Talking about higher-order uncertainty. Ms., Stanford University.

Leitgeb, Hannes. 2012. A probabilistic semantics for counterfactuals. Part A. The Review of Symbolic Logic 5(1). 26–84.

Lewis, David. 1979. Scorekeeping in a language game. Journal of Philosophical Logic 8(1). 339–359.

Lucas, Christopher G. & Charles Kemp. 2015. An improved probabilistic account of counterfactual reasoning. Psychological Review 122(4). 700–734.

MacFarlane, John. 2003. Future contingents and relative truth. The philosophical Quarterly 53(212). 321–336.

Meek, Christopher & Clark Glymour. 1994. Conditioning and intervening. The

British journal for the philosophy of science 45. 1001–1021.

Moss, Sarah. 2015. On the semantics and pragmatics of epistemic vocabulary. Semantics and Pragmatics 8. 1–81.

Pearl, Judea. 2000. Causality: Models, Reasoning and Inference. Cambridge University Press.

Rips, L. 2010. Two causal theories of counterfactual conditionals. Cognitive science 34(2). 175–221.

Santorio, Paolo. 2016. Interventions in premise semantics. Philosophers’ Imprint.

Schaffer, Jonathan. 2004. Counterfactuals, causal independence and conceptual circularity. Analysis 64(284). 299–308.

Schulz, Katrin. 2007. Minimal models in semantics and pragmatics: Free choice, exhaustivity, and conditionals: ILLC, University of Amsterdam PhD dissertation.

Schulz, Katrin. 2011. “If you’d wiggled A, then B would’ve changed”: Causality and counterfactual conditionals. Synthese 179(2). 239–251.

Sloman, Steven A. 2005. Causal Models: How We Think About the World and its Alternatives. OUP.

Sloman, Steven A & David A Lagnado. 2005. Do we “do”? Cognitive Science 29(1). 5–39.

Slote, Michael A. 1978. Time in counterfactuals. The Philosophical Review 87(1). 3–27.

Stalnaker, Robert. 2015. Counterfactuals and humean reduction. A Companion to David Lewis 57. 411.

Stalnaker, Robert & Richard Jeffrey. 1994. Conditionals as random variables. In Probability and conditionals: Belief revision and rational decision, 31–46. Cambridge University Press.

Swanson, Eric. 2006. Interactions With Context. Ph.D. thesis, MIT.

Swanson, Eric. 2011. How not to theorize about the language of subjective uncertainty.

Swanson, Eric. 2015. The application of constraint semantics to the language of subjective uncertainty. Journal of Philosophical Logic 1–26.

Tenenbaum, Joshua B., Charles Kemp, Tom L. Griffiths & Noah D. Goodman. 2011. How to grow a mind: Statistics, structure, and abstraction. Science 331(6022). 1279–1285.

Ülkümen, Gülden, Craig R Fox & Bertram F Malle. 2015. Two dimensions of

subjective uncertainty: Clues from natural language. To appear in Journal of Experimental Psychology: General.

Veltman, Frank. 1985. Logics for conditionals: University of Amsterdam PhD dissertation.

Veltman, Frank. 2005. Making counterfactual assumptions. Journal of Semantics 22(2). 159–180.

Yalcin, Seth. 2007. Epistemic modals. Mind 116(464). 983–1026.

Yalcin, Seth. 2010. Probability operators. Philosophy Compass 5(11). 916–937.

Yalcin, Seth. 2012. Context probabilism. In M. Aloni, V. Kimmelman, F. Roelofsen, G. W. Sassoon, K. Schulz & M. Westera (eds.), Logic, Language and Meaning 7218 Lecture Notes in Computer Science, 12–21. Springer.

Zhao, Michael. 2015. Intervention and the probabilities of indicative conditionals. The Journal of Philosophy 112(9). 477–503.