A new case of pragmatically deviant embedded disjunctions

Milica Denić

Abstract


In this paper, we discuss a novel observation that sentences such as ‘#Each of these three girls is Mary, Susan, or Jane’ are deviant. Its deviance is surprising: the sentence should convey that one of the three girls is Mary, another one of them is Susan, and yet another one is Jane; however, it cannot be naturally used to do so. We will propose that the deviance is caused by ignorance inferences which contradict common knowledge. If the proposal is on the right track, ignorance inferences need to be derived blindly to common knowledge, similarly to what has been proposed for scalar implicatures by Magri (2009).

 


Full Text:

PDF


DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.3765/salt.v28i0.4432

Copyright (c) 2018 Milica Denić